RECIPES / SOUTHERN CLASSICS
Southern Brown Rice
Not the whole grain kind. This is the church cookbook casserole where long grain white rice bakes in beef consomme and French onion soup until it turns deep brown.
BY FELICITY KENNEDY
CO-FOUNDER AT 4SISTERS / AUGUST 17, 2026
ON THIS PAGE
Overview
Ingredients
Prep
Baking
SERVES 8
PREP
10 min
COOK
1 hr 15 min
SERVES
8
RICE
Long grain
A Naming Problem, Not a Whole Grain
Serving
FAQ
RICE WE USED
Southern brown rice contains no brown rice. The name describes the color the dish turns, not the grain in it, and the grain is long grain white rice baked in canned beef consomme and French onion soup with a stick of butter.
Parboiled White Rice
32 oz (2 lb) bag
Organic White Rice
We sell actual whole grain brown rice, so we field this confusion more than most people. Somebody calls looking for the recipe their grandmother made, we ask whether they mean the casserole or the whole grain, and about half the time they did not know there were two things.
The casserole is the older use of the phrase in the South. You will also see it as browned rice, beefy rice, stick of butter rice, or company rice, and one well known recipe blog titles it Mama's Brown Rice and adds "not the healthy kind" to head off exactly this problem.
If you came here wanting whole grain, we have that too. Our Cajun brown rice with the trinity is made with real Organic Brown Rice. What follows is the casserole.
32 oz (2 lb) bag
SEE OUR RICE
The grain is long grain white rice, not whole grain. Brown rice will not work at these ratios or this timing.
Do not rinse the rice. Enriched rice carries its added nutrients on the surface and rinsing washes them off.
Use consomme, not condensed beef broth. Consomme is clarified and more concentrated, which is where the color comes from.
Bake covered for the first hour, then uncover for the last 15 minutes to dry the top.
Ingredients
1 1/2 cups 4Sisters Parboiled White Rice
2 cans beef consomme, 10.5 oz each
1 can French onion soup, 10.5 oz
1/2 cup unsalted butter, sliced thin
8 oz sliced mushrooms
1 tbsp Worcestershire sauce
1/2 tsp coarsely cracked black pepper
1/4 tsp garlic powder
2 green onions, sliced thin, to finish
No added salt, the canned soups carry plenty
Prep
1
Heat the oven and pick the dish
Heat the oven to 350 degrees. Use a 9 by 13 inch baking dish or a 3 quart casserole. This looks like far too much liquid for the amount of rice when you first pour it in, and that is correct, so do not use anything shallower.
2
Assemble it cold, in one dish
Scatter the dry rice across the bottom of the dish. Add the mushrooms, then pour over both cans of consomme, the French onion soup, and the Worcestershire. Stir once to distribute the rice evenly.
Lay the butter slices across the surface, spaced out, and sprinkle the black pepper and garlic powder over the top. Do not stir again. The butter should melt down into it from above.
The name describes the color the dish turns, not the grain in it. There is no whole grain anywhere near it.
Baking
3
Bake covered for one hour
Cover the dish tightly with foil and bake for 60 minutes. Do not open it. The rice is absorbing nearly four cups of seasoned liquid and every time the foil comes off, steam leaves that the rice needed.
4
Uncover and finish
Take the foil off and bake another 15 minutes, until the surface looks dry and the edges have darkened and pulled slightly from the sides of the dish. The color should be a deep, even brown throughout.
Let it stand 10 minutes before serving, then fluff with a fork and scatter the green onions over the top.
Finished Southern brown rice is soft and savory, closer to a pilaf than to a bowl of steamed rice, and the grains should still be distinct rather than creamed together. If there is liquid pooling at 75 minutes, give it another 10 uncovered. If the top has dried but the middle is firm, add a quarter cup of hot water, re-cover, and bake 10 more.
We use our parboiled rice here for a specific reason. This is a long, wet bake, and parboiled rice is steamed inside the husk before milling, which sets the starch and keeps the grains from breaking down over 75 minutes. Plain milled white rice works but comes out softer.
Parboiled rice is steamed in the husk before milling, which is why it survives a 75 minute wet bake.
TIP FROM THE FARM
This is a make-ahead dish. Assemble the whole thing up to a day in advance, cover it, and refrigerate without baking. Add 10 minutes to the covered stage to account for going in cold. It is the reason it shows up at every potluck and holiday table in this part of the country.
How We Serve It
Around here this goes next to roast beef, pork loin, or smothered chicken, and it turns up at Thanksgiving beside the dressing. It is rich enough that it does not need gravy, though nobody has ever objected to gravy on it.
It is genuinely a heritage recipe rather than a health one, and we would rather be straight about that than dress it up. If you want the whole grain, our Organic Brown Rice is certified 100% whole grain by the Whole Grains Council, and we compared the two in brown rice vs white rice.
Leftovers keep four days and reheat well covered with a splash of broth. More of what we cook is in our recipe collection.
Questions We Get
â–¾ Does Southern brown rice use brown rice?
No. It uses long grain white rice. The dish is called brown rice because the beef consomme and French onion soup turn the grains deep brown as they bake. Whole grain brown rice will not work with this liquid ratio or this timing, since it needs roughly twice as long to become tender. Recipes sometimes call it browned rice, beefy rice, or stick of butter rice to avoid the confusion.
â–¾ Can I substitute beef broth for the consomme?
You can, but the result is thinner and lighter in color. Consomme is clarified and more concentrated than broth, so it delivers more beef flavor and more of the browning. If you only have broth, use the same volume and add a tablespoon of Worcestershire plus a teaspoon of beef base to make up the difference.
â–¾ Why does my baked rice come out crunchy?
Either the foil was not sealed or the oven ran cool. This dish depends on trapped steam to move nearly four cups of liquid into a cup and a half of rice, and a loose corner of foil lets that escape. Crimp the foil tightly around the whole rim, and if it is still firm after 75 minutes, add a quarter cup of hot water, re-cover, and bake 10 minutes more.
FEATURED POSTS
TECHNIQUE
Sushi Rice, Done Properly
LOUISIANA CLASSICS
Authentic Dirty Rice
WEEKNIGHT
Black Beans and White Rice